tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post5517920040368171849..comments2023-10-30T08:40:59.016-04:00Comments on Wolfish Musings: Are Children Conceived Through IVF Spiritually Defective? -- Part IIBrooklynWolfhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/03994285019137108636noreply@blogger.comBlogger11125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-62260672222148852562017-05-04T15:01:11.098-04:002017-05-04T15:01:11.098-04:00"Like in a case where one must violate Shabbo..."Like in a case where one must violate Shabbos to save a life – no one would ever argue that saving this life wasn’t an incredible mitzvah. And yet, there’s Teshuva that needs to be done to rectify the “overridden” Shabbos. Or if a Rov instructs someone to break their fast on Yom Kippur, they should make up for the “lost” fast on another day"<br /><br />This paragraph is SHEKER GOMUR. If a mohel does a bris on Shabbos which is the eighth day, does he need to do "teshuva"? Mikehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03465908655851286361noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-41716692351593048542007-10-23T18:03:00.000-04:002007-10-23T18:03:00.000-04:00There actually is a "documented" source for most o...There actually is a "documented" source for most of the claims made here.<BR/><BR/>With no undue disrespect to Rabbi Friedman, who obviously knows a good deal about halacha and Jewish Hashkafa, and who represents a valid and recognised stream of Judaism these claim are carefully "documented" ...<BR/><BR/>In the writings of <B>Scientology</B> ... The movement behind these texts (Religious Technology Center) presents these texts as "Scientific Studies", but many scientists disagree ...<BR/><BR/>Now before anyone blows their top, please allow me to explain.<BR/><BR/>One of the big "Things" in Scientology is that being brought into this world incorrectly <I>demands</I> intensive (and expensive) Scientology courses/counseling/treatments. Coincidentally born and Bred Scientologists need these sessions too!!<BR/><BR/>According to the fundamentalist presentation of this idea, it is better for the child/mother to risk certain aspects of childbirth (eg bloodflow problems to the brain potentially causing long term problems in the child) than to have the child live with the legacy of an incorrect birthing process.<BR/><BR/>The view of Judaism is the opposite of this. Nothing is more important than the short term situation of the mother/child. Every effort should be made, potentially violating (or should i say nullifying) other religious precepts in order to give the mother and child opportunity to build a life together, and have the strength to do what they need to do in this world.<BR/><BR/>Now I don't do "Chitas", but I know people who do, and I see it as a very valid and valuable seder limud (I, being from a different stream of Judaism have a different seder limud) but it is insulting to claim it is a <I>tikkun</I> for such defects. In fact virtually every full on Chabad person I know does Chitas, and most of them are surely lacking these "defects".<BR/><BR/>Unfortunately this is pop Psychology... Oh ... you have a problem ... do Chitas ... this is insulting to the Rebbes of Chabad.<BR/><BR/>More honest would be to say ... "You want to grow spiritually ... do Chitas .. then be-ezras Hashem yisborach you will gain the spiritual strength to overcome your own Nisyonos"extratorahhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15556349275929101468noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-20792525937617360992007-10-17T23:26:00.000-04:002007-10-17T23:26:00.000-04:00So to put it incredibly bluntly physical contact b...So to put it incredibly bluntly physical contact between private parts is more important than the conception that results. My psychological take on it is that some Chassidim are a little bit too hung-up and repressed for their own good while at the same time a bit too pre-occupied with sex.<BR/><BR/>Good thing my wife and I aren't and accept that G-d has provided another avenue to conception than the one which hasn't worked for a decade of trying. She should remain barren then? No, I fail to see how IVF/etc are unholy. Men and women are doing me a kindness by dedicating their intellectual lives to find a way for us to have a child. I am thankful for that.-suitepotato-https://www.blogger.com/profile/04567987879881511630noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-37891736989270749272007-09-30T18:00:00.000-04:002007-09-30T18:00:00.000-04:00Recommending homeopathy makes me skeptical of the ...Recommending homeopathy makes me skeptical of the rest of the response.Orthonomicshttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07892074485262548496noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-47801780700279485762007-09-26T18:11:00.000-04:002007-09-26T18:11:00.000-04:00this is what happens when rabbis think they are ps...this is what happens when rabbis think they are psychologists and use psychological terms in a psychobabble fashion to bolster their arguments. just as i stick to my domain -- which is psychology -- let him stick to his. because psychology uses a lot or ordinary language terms does not mean that the layperson -- here the rabbi -- should be considered adn should consider himself proficient in the field. let me not get going. a while ago there was an article in one of the jewish weeklies by a teacher from lakewood who proudly declares that she has cured numerous cases of selective mutism. it is too stupid and too arrogant to bother educating these folks. <BR/>well, i know this is a sidepoint to this article by friedman -- very disturbing-- but i guess it got to me because i just came home from a day of work -- guess as one of those psychologists who actually went to school for years after the bachelor's in order to study this field which rabbi friedman picked up onthe fly.<BR/>well have a great sukkot. i need it.eglantinehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09109188899859707682noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-54527090341666902212007-09-26T03:00:00.000-04:002007-09-26T03:00:00.000-04:00"The same must be said of the importance and signi..."The same must be said of the importance and significance of the physical contact and relationship that leads to conception. It is simply irresponsible to take comfort in the mistaken belief that the absence of that intimacy will have no effect."<BR/>Total and utter bollocks.<BR/>The guy's a tosser. He doesn't know what he's talking about. Need anything more be said?<BR/>Why waste time on this rubbish? Next subject, please!Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-70185321399031073252007-09-26T02:10:00.000-04:002007-09-26T02:10:00.000-04:00A woman on Imamother brings the following sources ...A woman on Imamother brings the following sources (in italics) to support Rabbi Friedman's argument.<BR/><BR/><I>1) Igeres Hakodesh of the Ramban (ch. 5) discusses that thoughts during intimacy affect the form of the sperm (perhaps what's known as DNA today).</I><BR/><BR/>Considering that couples going through ART have to have scheduled intercourse, I can honestly say that during those times, our thoughts are pretty much solely on the hope that THIS TIME will be the time.<BR/><BR/><I>2) Gemarra Brachos (5b) and the Shulchan Aruch discuss the affects that the position of the bed (!) have on the child.</I><BR/><BR/>I would heartily agree the position of the bed is important to those of us using ART to conceive our children... how comfortable the stirrups are, the pelvic tilt just so...<BR/><BR/><I>3) Siddur Beis Yaakov discusses the affects of both actions and thoughts during intimacy. It's a very popular Seifer, used by both Kallah and Chosson teachers. R' Yaakov Emdin writes there how each aspect of intimacy affects the different senses of the child.<BR/>He also writes how sometimes a Jewish soul goes into a non-Jewish body who later converts, just because the parents had the right thoughts during intimacy (and vice versa ch"v). </I><BR/><BR/>See #1.<BR/><BR/><I>4) Tanya (ch. 2) quotes the Zohar and discusses the power the parents have to give their child better Levushim for the Neshama. These Levushim give the child a stronger character and a better ability to overcome the Yetzer Hara. </I><BR/><BR/>Again, see #1.<BR/><BR/><I>5) The infamous Bnei 9 Midos, who are children of parents who did not behave properly during intimacy, brought down in many Sefarim, including the Shulchan Aruch. Amongst them are children whose parents hated each other, were drunk, thought about others (fantasized), were thinking of divorce, one was sleeping and more. </I><BR/><BR/>If a couple were going through the expense and often indignity of fertility treatments, do you really think they'd be hating one another?<BR/><BR/>One of the things I have a problem with is the fact that they (the woman who posted the above and R' Friedman) combine intimacy and conception.<BR/><BR/>Conception is more likely to happen when a woman is cleaning the bathroom, washing dishes, folding laundry, filling the car with gas or taking out the garbage.<BR/><BR/>Not very holy times. Not exactly the moment when she is praying to Hashem for a child.<BR/><BR/>R' Friedman writes: <I>The same must be said of the importance and significance of the physical contact and relationship that leads to conception. It is simply irresponsible to take comfort in the mistaken belief that the absence of that intimacy will have no effect.</I><BR/><BR/>Who ever said there's an absence of physical contact and relationship?<BR/><BR/>Many of us who have gone through ART... believe me, when 'collecting the sperm sample' for IUI or IVF within the guidance of our Rabbis knowledgeable in Halachot and infertility, are sending out our most heartfelt prayer to haKadosh Baruch Hu that this time be a success. With all that goes on during 'collection', we and our partners are at our most committed to one another. Unless you've been through it, you cannot imagine the Mesirus Nefesh we AND OUR PARTNERS go through at this point... between the embarrassment of having to make a collection to rushing to the clinic within the allotted time to make the deposit (often with the sample in its cup, tucked in our bra or between our legs, if you'll excuse the vulgar image, to make sure it's kept as close to body temperature as possible).<BR/><BR/>During the procedure many of us, in a most undignified position will be reciting Tehillim. And there is not one day during that traditional '2 week wait' that we don't daven at least a dozen times that we're carrying a Bracha inside of us that we've gone to such lengths to make happen. If anything, the trials of ART brings us CLOSER to the Kedusha and understanding of where our children REALLY come from. If anything, a couple going through ART is MORE likely to be in the proper holy frame of mind at the actual time of conception.<BR/><BR/>I also find it ironic that Rabbi Friedman lists all sorts of post-birth traumas and yet fails to list Brit Milah. There is not one of us who has ever been to a Brit who can say that the baby in question is not experiencing SOME form of trauma at the time. Brit Milah is also one of those post-birth experiences that some men supposedly can remember and will forever be emotionally scarred. That reasoning is why so many people are anti-circumcision.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-21979836245550684002007-09-25T17:16:00.000-04:002007-09-25T17:16:00.000-04:00It is really hard to have any respect for such arr...It is really hard to have any respect for such arrogance and ignorance.<BR/><BR/>I need to get rid of his book now.<BR/><BR/>thanks for postingAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-14151934916741466692007-09-25T17:12:00.000-04:002007-09-25T17:12:00.000-04:00Oh, Lord. Where to begin?Friedman:The fact that a ...Oh, Lord. Where to begin?<BR/><BR/>Friedman:<BR/><I>The fact that a child is created from man and woman; the fact that the gestation period is nine months; the fact that birth involves contractions and labor; these are all necessary for the child’s future, as are all the other attending details. Should anything be changed or different, that would effect some quality or aspect of the baby’s health that would need to be compensated for.</I><BR/><BR/>Really... contractions and labor are necessary for the child's future? So what about cesarean births? Are children born from a scheduled C-section (like mine) also spiritually deficient? Listen to the absolute language he uses. "...<B>would</B> effect [sic] some quality or aspect of the baby’s health that would need to be compensated for." Amazing how he speaks with such confident authority. He <I>knows</I>.<BR/><BR/><I>Like the Torah tells us of the Monn food from heaven couldn’t satisfy like food from earth.</I><BR/><BR/>Um, where exactly does the Torah say that? Or is it a midrash, Rabbi Friedman?<BR/><BR/><I>If, for example, a child shows signs of alienation or distance and cant seem to warm up to a relationship, the first thing to consider is to remedy the absence of intimacy in his or her own birth process. </I><BR/><BR/>The FIRST thing? The very first thing, eh? Not his parents' relationship with their child or each other, not whether there was any other post-birth trauma or Ch'V abuse, but whether he was conceived through assisted reproductive methods. <BR/><BR/><BR/><I>(And I would strongly encourage to seek out a good homeopathic doctor who will find the right remedy for the individual child.)</I><BR/><BR/>Now Rabbi Friedman is giving health advice. What would a homeopath do, exactly? How is a 3X dilution of something going to counter a spiritual deficiency? Why not an iridologist? or a palm reader? Rabbi, your ignorance is really showing.<BR/><BR/><I>So when assisted reproduction is a necessary alternative and the circumstances are such that halacha allows it... </I><BR/><BR/>Why should halacha have to "allow" something that isn't inherently unallowable to begin with. Halacha doesn't have to allow me to drive a car on Sunday either.<BR/><BR/><I> But the original and natural method of conception holds benefit that this child will not be receiving...</I><BR/><BR/>HOW....DO...YOU...KNOW. <BR/><BR/>In God we trust. All others bring data.<BR/><BR/><I> It is true, as many have pointed out, that the Messiras Nefesh and emotional involvement of the parents in the assisted reproduction process, and the and deep bond it can create, may in fact compensate to a greater or lesser degree. But it is not a certainty that would render this conversation moot.</I><BR/><BR/>And Rabbi Friedman is certain of this.<BR/><BR/>He should be taken outside and soundly beaten with his black hat.Nice Jewish Guyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08143569412761938449noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-50770873284736705722007-09-25T14:37:00.001-04:002007-09-25T14:37:00.001-04:00What this meshuggener said isn't worthy of notice,...What this meshuggener said isn't worthy of notice, much less comment. It did evoke a few laughs.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-11425059.post-10209108585553378462007-09-25T14:37:00.000-04:002007-09-25T14:37:00.000-04:00There is no reason for the circumstances of concep...There is no reason for the circumstances of conception to have any affect on the baby that is ultimately born. The only parts of the unborn baby existing at conception are the sperm and egg. Neither of these cells have any kind of emotional memory. The DNA they contain can't be changed by the emotions of the parent.<BR/><BR/>Rabbi Friedman's sources seem shaky and he appears to be extrapolating.Lubab No Morehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15853466344401477725noreply@blogger.com